Episode 32
Can AI Replace the Human Voice?: Interview with Liz Solar
In this week's episode of Ongoing Mastery: Presenting & Speaking, Kirsten talks with voice over artist Liz Solar about the range of emotion in human voices and why kids complain the most about voices rendered with artificial intelligence.
Key take-aways:
- Performance is needed for human connection
- Good voice over work aids accessibility
- Playing an action is more effective than playing a personal quality, like eagerness
Rourke Training’s webpage: https://www.rourketraining.com/
Ongoing Masgtery: Presenting & Speaking page: https://ongoing-mastery.captivate.fm/
RSS feed: https://feeds.captivate.fm/ongoing-mastery/
Read a transcript of this episode: https://share.descript.com/view/5sEa81K1KyU
For the video version of this episode: https://youtu.be/fkRs7-j38G8
- Home | Liz Solar Voiceover
- EMBARK PODCAST | Liz Solar Voiceover
- Chewing the Scenery - TV Tropes -
- William Shatner's acting style, also called the Large Ham - TV Tropes
- Morgan Freeman's Famous Voice Didn't Happen By Accident
- NPR - Breaking News, Analysis, Music, Arts & Podcasts : NPR -
- Cameron Crowe on Philip Seymour Hoffman’s Genius in Iconic ‘Almost Famous’ Scene – Billboard -
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kirstenrourke/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/kirstenmalenarourke
Twitter: https://twitter.com/kirstenrourke?lang=en
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rourketraining/
Looking for a kick-ass speaking group? Use our affiliate link to join Innovation Women: https://bit.ly/innovationwomen
Transcript
Hello everyone and welcome to Ongoing Mastery:
Kirsten:Presenting & Speaking the podcast, the video show and the conversation.
Kirsten:So today we are doing an interview with Liz Solar.
Kirsten:Who.
Kirsten:Just she and I have no end of fun going back and forth on all things,
Kirsten:and I asked her to come on today to talk about her work as a voiceover
Kirsten:artist and all the ways in which ongoing mastery shows up in that genre.
Kirsten:So tell us about what you do.
Kirsten:What
Liz:I do is, so voiceover is actually the voice that you hear over picture.
Liz:That's basically what it is.
Liz:But you can also hear voiceover on your radio, on your phone, in
Liz:the train station at the airport.
Liz:Well, you can probably hear other things at the airport right now,
Liz:which we won't even discuss right now.
Liz:But voiceover is everywhere.
Liz:It's ubiquitous.
Liz:You can't stumble across social media without hearing.
Liz:Audio through voice accompanied by video.
Liz:That's just the way we're doing things now.
Liz:So basically I take a script, I interpret it, and I color it with some type of tone
Liz:or attitude, some type of personality.
Liz:Create a persona.
Liz:So whether that's a commercial or a narration or a video game, or an audiobook
Liz:or a telephone system, that's what I do.
Liz:It's all about blah, blah, blah,
Liz:. Kirsten: Fantastic.
Liz:I like that all about blah, blah, blah.
Liz:That would be a good t-shirt.
Liz:Well, you and I had talked about the fact that now a lot of e-learning audio is.
Liz:Becoming text to speech transcription, which is just AI, and that for low
Liz:level basic things, maybe that's fine, but I have a big concern of
Liz:what's being lost is the performance.
Liz:And that's one thing I wanted to talk about with you is because I
Liz:understand the cost saving issue, but no amount of programming in
Liz:AI is gonna get the inflections.
Liz:And the meaning across the way a human voice can.
Liz:And how do you get that across to people that don't like, don't
Liz:get that there's a performance
Liz:involved For some people, cost is always going to be the determinator
Liz:in terms of, this is what I want.
Liz:It's the least expensive route to go.
Liz:I'm going to do this.
Liz:Perhaps if you did a side by side test.
Liz:Apple now has several AI voices that I was listening to and I thought, you know what?
Liz:They're actually okay for 20, 30 seconds.
Liz:Do I want to hear hours of this?
Liz:Do I wanna hear an audio book read like this?
Liz:Because we have peaks and valleys.
Liz:You know, our voice, our pitches up when we get excited, it gets
Liz:lower, it gets more hushed.
Liz:I'm not sure that AI can do that, and I feel that way about
Liz:so many different types of AI.
Liz:There's a storytelling app now that you put in three or four facts that
Liz:you want to relay, and it comes out with the a story that's maybe two
Liz:pages long, and it is a template.
Liz:It's like the Hallmark cards version of story.
Kirsten:I'm making a face so the audio people can't see.
Kirsten:But I'm just picturing the look on Kellie's face when she produces
Kirsten:this podcast, who is the writer and is a literature professor.
Kirsten:The look on her face at that concept.
Kirsten:So
Liz:Kristen, this is an example.
Liz:My son and the kids are all about the ai.
Liz:They're excited by it.
Liz:I think understand the limitations, but also there's an excitement around ai.
Liz:Mm-hmm.
Liz:. So my son created a story.
Liz:and read it back.
Liz:And it was the most vanilla, mundane fifth grade, no offense to fifth grade
Liz:writers, but it was the most basic type of story that you could tell.
Liz:And it was really silly.
Liz:And even the tags that they put, the dialogue tags that
Liz:they put were really silly.
Liz:They were very earnest, like people were frowning and smiling and distressed . It
Liz:was okay, just, I'm a writer as well, so.
Liz:Mm.
Liz:I was listening to it and I thought, even if you're writing
Liz:a children's story, there's a lot more, there's more feeling behind it.
Liz:So until, and there's probably that time when the AI will sound pretty compelling.
Liz:I'm not sure that you can program emotion into any of it.
Kirsten:Hmm.
Kirsten:Yeah, it's interesting cause I, I mean, I do want to be moving forward with science
Kirsten:and moving forward with technology.
Kirsten:And I was at Dev learn the e-learning conference and was in the expo hall.
Kirsten:And all the way in the corner was a vendor who was showing off their
Kirsten:technology, which was, they take a photo of you and then they use transformation
Kirsten:technology to make the mouth move and they, they just, Voiceover so that that
Kirsten:way you don't have to, you know, do it.
Kirsten:So it's an AI voice that's like your voice, but it's your face just talking.
Kirsten:And I'm sitting there or standing there and the guy's pitching it to
Kirsten:me, he's like, this is wonderful.
Kirsten:And I couldn't.
Kirsten:I could not bring up, like I just didn't feel like I could say, this is horrifying
Kirsten:me to my core as a professional speaker, as someone who teaches for a living.
Kirsten:This hurts my soul.
Kirsten:So I was politely going, it's very interesting.
Kirsten:And I walked away going, oh God.
Kirsten:And I don't wanna not be open to things, but it's also like, I just, I guess my
Kirsten:concern is that it seems like people don't understand the degree of performance
Kirsten:that is needed for human Connect.
Kirsten:. And whether it's education, whether it's entertainment, there needs to be, there
Kirsten:needs to be performance, doesn't there?
Kirsten:I mean, that's what it seems like to me.
Liz:I agree.
Liz:There are voice actors who love the idea of AI.
Liz:They feel it's passive income, so bring it on.
Liz:And other people who feel that AI, it's just not part of their brand.
Liz:They won't.
Liz:I'm not sure whether it's a, you know, a morality thing, whether
Liz:it's a taste thing, whether it's a purest thing about, this is my voice.
Liz:I'm going to use it in this way and I'm going to use it in the moment, and it
Liz:will be a performance and it will not be somebody who's manipulating it, you know,
Liz:behind a curtain through some machinery.
Liz:So there's that.
Liz:One thing I can tell you anecdotally is that I have done projects
Liz:for kids that are like K-12.
Liz:Mm-hmm.
Liz:. So there's a lot of that educational textbook stuff, and it's such a service
Liz:for kids who have learning disabilities.
Liz:Dyslexia might have even some.
Liz:Audio processing problems, but they can go back and listen to it and listen
Liz:to it again until they can really embody some of those messages that
Liz:they might not get the first time.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:But what was coming back was the big complainers of AI are kids.
Liz:It doesn't sound real or it wasn't engaging them on some level.
Liz:I'm not even sure that they could pinpoint why.
Liz:Interesting.
Liz:They knew that it wasn't grabbing them and I, you know, out of the mouths of babes.
Liz:Okay.
Kirsten:Yeah, so I, yeah.
Kirsten:Cause I'm thinking in terms of, there was an e-learning project that I was
Kirsten:doing, which was cybersecurity, and what we did was we did a graphic novel.
Kirsten:And so I got one of my VO people to come in and Tim did two characters and
Kirsten:one of them was the chief of the spy service and his name, it was Steel,
Kirsten:and it was, he sent me the first take and in a note saying this might
Kirsten:be too much, and I sent him back.
Kirsten:I love it.
Kirsten:Love it because he chewed scenery like nobody's business.
Kirsten:And it was perfect.
Kirsten:And it, the next one, you know, the other one was a very straight up read,
Kirsten:but the chief was like this full William Shatner performance, and he was a
Kirsten:little like, this is probably too much.
Kirsten:I'm like, no, you nailed it.
Kirsten:That's exactly right.
Kirsten:And it's won awards.
Liz:Well, especially when you're doing that sounds almost like
Liz:a gaming version of mm-hmm.
Liz:E-Learning as well.
Liz:And we're always looking for those characters that are a little bit larger
Liz:than life archetypal or stereotypical.
Liz:And we'll hear it in commercial sometimes where it's that
Liz:cheesy furniture sale copy.
Liz:Yep.
Liz:But it's about something else, like maybe it's about a pharmaceutical
Liz:and they're trying to make a point.
Liz:About how bad it is to sell to people that way, or convince people that way.
Liz:You know, hurry up now.
Liz:N nobody's listening to that.
Liz:Or I, I'm not sure who is listening to that and being persuaded, but I think
Liz:sometimes you have to go big to make those
Kirsten:points.
Kirsten:Yeah.
Kirsten:And uh, what I'm hoping is with ai, and especially with with voiceover work in
Kirsten:this kind of work, I'm hoping that yes.
Kirsten:it has a foothold in some small, in some areas, but that people really
Kirsten:start to understand the power of story and the power of performance
Kirsten:so that people like you are brought in to do the specialist work.
Kirsten:Because I just don't think, I mean, you can tag the hell out of a a file to have
Kirsten:the AI read it differently, but I think there comes a point at which you're like,
Kirsten:but I wanna get different takes on it.
Kirsten:And that requires a.
Liz:It does.
Liz:Unless you have an entirely different library of a, a different mood.
Liz:And I'm wondering, and I don't know the science behind it, how
Liz:does the AI know when to bring up a voice where somebody's excited?
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:And really pitching their voice, hi, we have to hurry up.
Liz:We have a burning building.
Liz:Most of it is fairly flat.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:And, and I say this as somebody who, years ago I booked my first one of those
Liz:big, crazy phone systems, which was hundreds of thousands of phrases and
Liz:numbers and libraries of dates and years and Wow, it's like 15 years worth of it.
Liz:But I've done several of those project.
Liz:and the reason why those became so popular was they supplanted
Liz:actual customer service.
Liz:Oh, departments.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Where people used to pick up the phone.
Liz:And I can remember reading the New York Times, maybe 15, 16 years ago,
Liz:where they were talking about these giant phone systems, and they said,
Liz:whenever somebody calls customer service at a big company, it's $40 per call.
Liz:To speak with a human, but it's 40 cents per call to speak with a recorded system.
Liz:Ah, okay.
Liz:So it's, for some people it's always going to be about the money, the the
Liz:cost savings, about the economics.
Liz:What's interesting is the very good phone systems actually have great
Liz:live personal service as well.
Liz:Personal customer service, so you can reach a human more
Liz:easily on those better systems.
Liz:Hmm.
Liz:That would be
Kirsten:Glia Coffee.
Kirsten:Glia Coffee would be one of those.
Kirsten:Yes.
Kirsten:. Liz: So you know one of them.
Kirsten:Yeah.
Kirsten:I, uh, Sorry,
Liz:go ahead.
Liz:No, there are several like that.
Liz:You know, my client is a huge banking insurance corporation and
Liz:they almost every year are one of the top businesses in Business Week
Liz:Magazine for their customer service.
Kirsten:I, so the reason I've mentioned Gali is just because I remember when I
Kirsten:was regularly buying it, I would call in every once in a while and they would
Kirsten:get the automated, this was a while ago.
Kirsten:The automated service wasn't great, but it was fine.
Kirsten:But I would always, I'm one of those people that skips, I want to go
Kirsten:talk to the human and every single time their customer service people
Kirsten:were the best trained customer service people I've ever encount.
Kirsten:They were flawless and I know how hard that job is and I was just always like,
Kirsten:wow, somebody really knows what's going on on the back end because they, they
Kirsten:handled like, they handled everything, including not knowing what to do.
Kirsten:Like they handled it beautifully.
Kirsten:There was never a moment where they were snowing you, they were putting
Kirsten:you on hold to just go figure it out.
Kirsten:They're like, I don't know, and I need to find out.
Kirsten:So gimme your.
Kirsten:And then I'm gonna call you back like it was totally upfront, all of it,
Kirsten:100%, completely clear communication.
Kirsten:And it was like, wow.
Kirsten:And I did business with them, partly because I was so impressed
Kirsten:by the fact that clearly somebody in the company had the commitment.
Liz:And you want to support a company like that.
Liz:And in some of the work that I've done in some of the voiceover scripts,
Liz:including this one, they had a very clear idea of who their customer
Liz:was, why they were coming to them, what the values were of that person.
Liz:There have been clients who have given me one or two pages
Liz:of what a persona is like.
Liz:This is our.
Liz:One or two pages.
Liz:Yes.
Liz:Wow.
Liz:This is, it was a biography of this person, their age, where they
Liz:lived, what their interests were.
Liz:Holy cow.
Liz:Related to, yes.
Kirsten:That's wonderful.
Liz:Quite effective.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Mm.
Liz:It was work done at the beginning.
Liz:Mm-hmm.
Liz:so that they could have this ongoing persona.
Liz:I've been engaged with this company for 15 years.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:And remained with them because they were so clear about their intention.
Liz:Oh,
Kirsten:that's lovely.
Kirsten:That's wonderful.
Kirsten:But
Liz:isn't that.
Liz:I'm sorry, Kirsten, isn't that part of what you do?
Liz:You have an intention when you're going in mm-hmm.
Liz:and you're presenting a training, an idea to people, you know
Liz:where you're going with it.
Liz:I mean, people might ask you a question and it might change the direction a
Liz:little bit, or you're making, you know, someone's making an observation mm-hmm.
Liz:, and you're stopping down to take that in, and sometimes that might change.
Liz:It doesn't change the talk, but it might change a direction for a few
Liz:moments because you're, you're receptive to that as well, but you're going
Liz:in with the intention to present a certain bunch of ideas, values, mm-hmm.
Liz:education.
Liz:Yep.
Kirsten:Yeah.
Kirsten:No, I, I love, I just love the fact that it was multiple pages,
Kirsten:cuz normally I think wouldn't, normally you'd get maybe a paragraph
Liz:if.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:If sometimes, you know, the specs will say, and the specs are the
Liz:directions that they wanna take this copy in, a lot of times it will
Liz:just say, sound like Morgan Freeman,
Liz:You know, like, how are you supposed to do that?
Liz:Well, they don't, you know, Everybody.
Liz:Morgan Freeman used to be a big one, or Scarlet and Hanson and you know,
Liz:essentially, or Meryl Streep, you know?
Liz:Okay.
Liz:In really they're archetypes, you know.
Liz:What do you think of when you think of Morgan Freeman?
Liz:Like what does he, what feeling does he instill in people?
Liz:What they're trying to do is get to the essence of who Morgan Freeman is.
Liz:I mean, I'm certainly not going to do it.
Liz:I don't have his talent.
Liz:I don't have his voice.
Liz:But what?
Liz:But what is it that he has mm-hmm.
Liz:that they're looking for that you can distill and say, okay,
Liz:that's the feeling that I get when I listen to Morgan Freeman.
Liz:I feel safe.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:I feel respected.
Liz:You know, all of those things.
Liz:Okay,
Kirsten:so then let me ask you to give some advice to the viewers
Kirsten:and the listeners if they are gonna be, you know, well said is a is an
Kirsten:app that is, is doing pretty well, but, oops, hold on one second.
Kirsten:I'm gonna mute and I'm gonna explain to my son that we're still on the air.
Kirsten:Hold on one second.
Kirsten:. Okay.
Kirsten:And normally I would re rerecord this, but No, that's okay.
Kirsten:We're just gonna roll with it because this is what live recording is.
Kirsten:Yeah.
Kirsten:, my teenagers in the other room.
Kirsten:Oops.
Kirsten:So if someone is bringing in a voiceover artist, what are the things
Kirsten:that you really, really love for people to give you, for information?
Kirsten:Like, if you could have a, a just short dream list of the
Kirsten:things that people often forget.
Kirsten:What sort of information do you want?
Liz:People often forget what's the action?
Liz:They'll use words like lush or energetic.
Liz:A lot of times they'll say, no announcers.
Liz:They don't want you to sound like the announcer.
Liz:And then what you see right underneath it is announcer colon.
Liz:and what they say.
Liz:It's like, well you just put an announcer there.
Liz:. It's much more, I think, serviceable to ask somebody to play an action.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Play resent.
Liz:Play resentment.
Liz:You mean?
Liz:You know the political odds.
Liz:They're all about resentment and anger and all that.
Liz:You know, be angry, you know.
Liz:Show anger, show seduction.
Liz:You know, we eat cha wheat, chocolate, what's gonna get me to eat chocolate?
Liz:Nothing like, you know, you're talking about love language now.
Liz:. Excellent.
Liz:A lot of times it is getting the, what's the, what's the action behind that?
Liz:Not just the action that I'm taking.
Liz:How do you want me to make you feel?
Liz:Ah, make you feel safe?
Liz:Okay.
Liz:You know, look, I'm thinking right now, Southwest Airlines.
Liz:I wanna get in on that action.
Liz:Oh, because, I'm taking a huge leap, getting on your plane, make me feel safe.
Liz:Make me not regret this.
Liz:Assure me that my experience is going to be fine and I won't be spending
Liz:the, you know, next three or four days lying on a bench in a, an airport.
Liz:Yeah, they,
Kirsten:they need you
Liz:right now.
Liz:You know, first of all, , they do, you know, know, know who you are and
Liz:what you know, who you're selling to.
Liz:There's, there's some, you know, what I've seen sometimes is we're
Liz:looking for a middle-aged female.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Here I am, 25 to 35 years old.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:. That's interesting.
Liz:Middle-aged.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Yeah, definitions have changed about middle-aged or you know, like the kid
Liz:who's giving these directions is 18 and 25 probably feels middle-aged to them.
Liz:I have no idea, but that, that is not very helpful.
Liz:Or people will say earnest.
Liz:Earnest, but lighthearted.
Liz:Fun but serious.
Liz:Uh, could you pick part of this list,
Kirsten:Which ones?
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:Because in a, in a conversation, I mean, you, and you don't wanna go
Liz:in with one, you know, be serious.
Liz:It's like, okay, we can be serious.
Liz:But even when we're having a serious conversation, the tone changes.
Liz:We color things.
Liz:There are mm-hmm.
Liz:, fla, you know, think of food a lot.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:There was flavors.
Liz:Flavors to things.
Liz:There's a color to thing.
Liz:Am am I making it dark?
Liz:Am I making it too dark?
Liz:Am I scaring people?
Liz:That's why you hear so many pharmaceuticals now that seem lighter.
Liz:Oh.
Liz:Cause before it used to be, you know, now it's, you know, take
Liz:this and you'll feel better.
Liz:And those side effects include all these things that can kill you.
Liz:You . So it's , it's
Kirsten:Yes.
Liz:Insane.
Liz:That's, but it's a little bit more lighthearted.
Liz:You know, people experience, you know, if you experience this, you know, call your
Liz:doctor . Whoa, you know, I'm not taking.
Liz:I don't,
Kirsten:I don't care how much, if you experience a burning
Kirsten:rash, please call your doctor.
Kirsten:Yes.
Kirsten:. Liz: Right?
Kirsten:I mean, I, I used to have a, a friend who, when biographers came out and
Kirsten:they said, you know, if you have an erection for more than four hours, you
Kirsten:know, he said, if you have an erection for more than four hours, call me
Kirsten:I like it.
Kirsten:I like it.
Kirsten:Yes.
Kirsten:Here's my number.
Kirsten:Yes.
Kirsten:And give me some of those pills.
Kirsten:Right.
Liz:So, you know, part of it is we certain things that have be
Liz:been very, uh, serious in the past.
Liz:Like you never see an insurance ad now that's not funny
Liz:or not trying to be funny.
Liz:Ah, true.
Liz:True.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:You know, Liberty Mutual has all these, like, you know, birds descending,
Liz:the seagulls descending as people are having pie eating contests.
Liz:Or you have the guy iu, was it limu, iu, you know, the, his
Liz:Doug, or whatever his name is.
Liz:See how well I'm remembering these commercials, but there's a lot
Liz:more humor being infused in it.
Liz:And the, that's the other piece is knowing what's expected in the market
Liz:because ah, styles, styles change.
Liz:Styles do change.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:. Even the way people talk, people of my generation speak differently than a Gen Z.
Liz:Mm.
Liz:Okay.
Liz:Their patterns, their slang changes.
Liz:So when I see something, even if I can get there vocally and make
Liz:myself sound younger, because we can do that, I can't make myself
Liz:be that because it feels weird.
Liz:Mm-hmm.
Liz:It feels e emotionally, I can't get there unless I'm kind of making fun.
Liz:Yeah, it, it's kind of like then, then I'm the, then I'm the mom making fear.
Liz:You're the mom.
Kirsten:Yeah.
Kirsten:It's like when NPR tries to use modern slang and it always is
Kirsten:one of those moments where I'm listening, going, please stop.
Kirsten:Please, please stop.
Kirsten:It's like, it sounds like you're saying I'm so hip, you know, or something.
Liz:and it's, I love npr.
Liz:It's my chosen, you know, news.
Liz:But I've always felt you need a sense of humor and you need a good sense of humor.
Liz:They're, they're not.
Liz:They try, they try, they
Kirsten:try, but it's, it's usually like, please don't, please stop.
Kirsten:I know , and here's the, oh, sorry.
Kirsten:Go ahead.
Kirsten:No, go ahead.
Kirsten:No, go ahead.
Kirsten:Well, I was gonna say that unfortunately, I'm trying to keep
Kirsten:these within a time window, but I do wanna talk to you more about this.
Kirsten:So I'm actually gonna ask if you can come back and do
Kirsten:another one, because, oh, sure.
Kirsten:I wanna get some more, more details about voice work for people, because you've
Kirsten:been, well, for one, you've been in the.
Kirsten:I mean, you started when you were two.
Liz:I did.
Liz:It was back in 1874
Liz:. Kirsten: But you've been
Liz:So while I actually do wanna keep talking to you for the next 20
Liz:minutes, I'm mindful that Kelly is, is gonna go, you know, we're
Liz:trying to keep these in a window.
Liz:So where can people find you?
Liz:People can find me, people can find me@lizsolr.com.
Liz:L I Z S O L A R.
Liz:I have a podcast as well, on which you will be appearing or yes,
Liz:heard, and it's called Embark.
Liz:And um, that's kind of it.
Liz:Every once in a while you'll hear me, uh, on a commercial or.
Liz:on an e-learning app.
Kirsten:Oh, fantastic.
Kirsten:So when, when you come back, I would really, I would really love for us
Kirsten:to get into what different voices you can do, like different ways
Kirsten:of communicating the same message.
Kirsten:Cuz I really wanna get across the performance aspect that I don't,
Kirsten:I don't know if people realize.
Kirsten:The depth that voiceover artists go to.
Kirsten:So,
Liz:yes.
Liz:Can I leave that?
Liz:Can I give something to like, hang on to Yeah.
Liz:So one of, one of my favorite actors is the late Phillips Seymour Hoffman.
Liz:Mm.
Liz:Yeah.
Liz:And love him was just a chameleon in terms of performing.
Liz:He was in this movie from the early two thousands called almost famous.
Liz:it's the coming of age, uh, film about a young boy who was writing for Rolling
Liz:Stone Magazine, following a, a rock band, and he plays this character called
Liz:Luster Banks, who is a real person who wrote for Rolling Stone Magazine, right?
Liz:So he gives this speech at the end, and the director was expecting
Liz:it to be all loud and yelling and angry, and he made it this incredib.
Liz:Intimate conversation, late night phone call with this young kid and
Liz:totally blew the directors away.
Liz:Sometimes we just wanna be surprised because everybody will go for that
Liz:angry thing and the person who goes left with something, even if it's not
Liz:the right thing in the moment, people will remember, oh, they did something
Liz:different and that was interest.
Liz:that was distinctive.
Kirsten:And that's where the performance comes in and that's
Kirsten:where the art of it comes in.
Kirsten:So, so thank you.
Kirsten:Cuz I, I definitely want, when anybody's listening and when
Kirsten:anybody's coming to the, the work, the ongoing mastery is performance
Kirsten:and the art that people like you do.
Kirsten:I just really want people to start seeing the depths of it and the
Kirsten:layers and the flavors of it, because it's not just reading a script.
Kirsten:not even close, not even.
Kirsten:As someone who has tried to do VO for E-learning and then hired people
Kirsten:because I realized that I could read the words, but I couldn't perform them
Kirsten:the way they needed to be performed.
Kirsten:. And that's why I was always like, could we hire somebody?
Kirsten:And they're like, well, we could do text to speech.
Kirsten:I'm like, we could, if you want people to be miserable and be
Kirsten:sitting in the e-learning going, ugh.
Kirsten:It's like human connection.
Kirsten:Hello.
Kirsten:That's just my thing.
Kirsten:Okay, so I'm gonna have to wrap this because again, , I'm
Kirsten:picturing Kelly's face and she's gonna be listening to this going.
Kirsten:Why did you bring me up four times?
Kirsten:So everybody thank you for watching.
Kirsten:Thank you for listening.
Kirsten:Come to the Ongoing Mastery: Presenting & Speaking LinkedIn group.
Kirsten:Please go to Liz's website and check out her work and we will come back and
Kirsten:do some voices and I will, you know, listen to all the different characters
Kirsten:and that'll be a hell of a lot of fun.
Kirsten:And other than that, we will see you all next time.
Kirsten:Have a great one and see you next.
Kirsten:Bye.